Kirkus Reviews QR Code
IN MEMORIAM by Alice Winn Kirkus Star

IN MEMORIAM

by Alice Winn

Pub Date: March 7th, 2023
ISBN: 9780593534564
Publisher: Knopf

Love between two young men is tough enough in 1914; the fact that they are both fighting in World War I makes it…tougher.

The two moneyed teens, Sidney Ellwood and Henry Gaunt, are boarding school students in England just before the Great War begins. Between them, they harbor enough secrets to propel the plots of several books, and one of the wonderful aspects of Winn’s debut is that, just when you think you’ve settled into a tender literary novel, its revelations and surprises begin to unfurl at an impressive pace that reads more like a thriller. Sidney is Jewish but thoroughly denies it; Henry, or Heinrich, has lived in England for most of his life but is half German, a dangerous fact as the war begins. Winn lovingly re-creates British boarding school life during this era, the camaraderie among the boys but also the snarling viciousness of the place. Sidney and Henry love one another but, perhaps understandably, have little ability to assess each other’s feelings, much less possess any insight about how to express their love. To prove their British bonafides and to compensate for the accusation that his uncle is a German traitor, Henry’s family encourages him to enlist. Sidney, obsessed with Tennyson's empire-loving verse and enamored with Henry’s bravery, also signs up. Neither of them are yet 19, the youngest age England accepts its soldiers. Winn’s battle scenes are hair-raising and terrifying, but her portraits of Sidney and Henry are intimate and evocative. They are two very young men who know so little of the world and then suddenly know its deep depravity thanks to the war. Watching them search for each other across a damaged Europe makes for a love story that's hard to forget.

A powerful, deeply imagined debut.