Kirkus Reviews QR Code
IF ANIMALS TRICK-OR-TREATED by Ann Whitford Paul

IF ANIMALS TRICK-OR-TREATED

From the If Animals Kissed Good Night series

by Ann Whitford Paul ; illustrated by David Walker

Pub Date: July 19th, 2022
ISBN: 978-0-374-38852-2
Publisher: Farrar, Straus and Giroux

We’ve seen how Paul and Walker’s adorable animals celebrate Thanksgiving; what about Halloween?

All the Halloween check boxes are ticked for the littlest listeners, and Paul zooms in on Mama and little Owlet at they complete each one: carving pumpkins, decorating, donning costumes, and trick-or-treating. Interspersed among these, other animals join in on the festivities. Bat adds fangs to her pumpkin, and “Hatchling would beg Papa Crocodile / to carve his pumpkin a sneee-eery smile.” (Cleverly, their pumpkin croc features an oblong pumpkin carved sideways with successively smaller pumpkins for the body.) Bushes and trees get festooned with spiderwebs and orange-and-black steamers, and, somewhat disturbingly, “Vulture chicks would scat-scatter fresh skeleton bones / close to a cluster of old tombstones.” Costumes include the traditional (superhero, mummy, witch) as well as some creative twists (Zebra Foal wears “a costume of spots” that resembles a giraffe’s hide; Little Leopard dons a striped costume). Treats match the giver: Parrot gives seeds, Armadillo passes out chocolate ants, and Raccoon offers “garbage-fudge squares.” Page turns and line breaks sometimes interrupt the rhythm of the verses, though the rhymes are pretty spot-on. Walker’s scenes start during the day and gradually fade to night, when the illustrations almost seem to glow, gentle stars in the sky shining down, and the shared book at the close is the ideal end to a busy day.(This book was reviewed digitally.)

A cute introduction to Halloween for youngsters.

(Picture book. 3-7)