Kirkus Reviews QR Code
EXTRAORDINARY ALBERT by Bonnie Grubman

EXTRAORDINARY ALBERT

by Bonnie Grubman ; illustrated by S.K.Y. van der Wel

Pub Date: March 23rd, 2021
ISBN: 978-1-60537-592-2
Publisher: Clavis

A gorilla child learns to accept an aspect of his physical appearance in this Dutch/Flemish import.

A mother and father gorilla welcome their newborn son into the world. Albert has large feet, something the entire family, even Albert, appreciates—that is, until he grows older and starts to resent them, wishing he had “perfect feet” like his friend Rex, a brown monkey. One day, the two friends get lost in heavy rain while playing in the jungle, and it’s Albert’s large footprints that save the day and lead them home. The author drives the message home when Rex tells Albert: “I wish I had feet like yours. You’re my hero, Albert.” The illustrator, using a palette dominated by the greens of a jungle, anthropomorphizes the family’s world in every way: Baby Albert uses a bottle and plays with human toys and, later, sleeps in a bed. It’s refreshing to see two male characters display affection for each other in a time of need: When Rex gets scared at one point, Albert wraps him in a hug (using those big feet) and comforts him. But at the same time, some readers may be dismayed to see anthropomorphized simians, which have traditionally been used in the U.S. to dehumanize Black people, once again at play in a picture book. The story lacks nuance; as a result, its message of self-acceptance falls flat. (This book was reviewed digitally with 10.2-by-19.6-inch double-page spreads viewed at actual size.)

A second-rate story in need of a visual overhaul.

(Picture book. 4-9)