WHAT IF ONE DAY...

Handy’s latest picture book explores what might happen should different parts of our world suddenly be erased.

“What if one day…all the birds flew away?” Or if “all the water disappeared?” How about if there were no plants or colors or people? This text gets readers thinking about aspects of our world that can easily be taken for granted. It offers some gentle consequences, like worms relaxing in birds’ absence, before pivoting to ask readers to imagine what might be missing one day “because it hadn’t been dreamt of yet.” The well-intended attempt at encouraging readers’ thoughtfulness is undermined by some oversights. Namely, for many readers, such as those who live in areas threatened by climate change and deforestation or without access to clean water, these are not what-if scenarios; they are current or looming realities that are dismissed each time Handy insists “but there is water” or “but there are birds.” The book’s conceit—calling upon children to use their imaginations to envision how the world might look—is promising, but instead of empowering readers to create meaning for themselves, the text gets more muddled the closer they look. Depicting racially diverse characters, Corrin’s full, vibrant spreads convey movement and stillness, humor and pensiveness, hitting just the right visual tones, but the writing doesn’t quite manage to live up to the artwork.

Readers will need to mind the gap between this book’s premise and what it actually delivers.