THE PLAYMAKERS

An Ohio boy puts together his own basketball team of mismatched seventh graders.

When best friends Jax and Nic are cut from the middle school basketball team, Jax impulsively tells their coach, “We’ll make our own team. And we’ll be better than yours.” Luke, who’s 6 feet, 3 inches tall, is more interested in acting than basketball, but he doesn’t get a part in the school play. Jax recruits Luke as a player in exchange for taking part in a theater competition with him. Eventually, the team members connect with intelligent, precocious, and lonely classmate Miley, who wants to improve her sports statistics skills: Helping the team improve their play would give her great college application material. The story is told through Jax’s, Luke’s, and Miley’s alternating first-person points of view. Miley’s entries appear as doodle-filled graphic journal entries. Full of drama, miscalculations, and turnovers, this story explores a fun scenario in which a bunch of kids with different interests and skills work together for a common purpose. Unfortunately, the innocent fun is undermined by racialized portrayals of two teammates in the otherwise largely white-presenting cast. Nic is cued Black, and his father is in jail, while teammate Koa, who’s cued Pasifika, is repeatedly described in an othering way that references his “bush of curly hair” and the nickname “Animal” (from his old school); he’s also “been through some stuff” that’s similar to Nic’s trauma.

A heartfelt mix of basketball, theater, math, and friendship that’s marred by stereotypical representation.