ROBIN ROBIN

Any character in this picture book could be the main character in a different book.

Robin often speaks in rhyme: “Leave no trace, go tiptoe pace.” The mice who adopted her when her egg fell out of a nest speak mostly in short sentences, mostly about food, with exclamation points at the end: “Breadcrumbs!” “Pie crumbs!” “Cookie crumbs!” The book as a whole is technically a holiday story, but it’s the least Christmassy of Christmas books. The tree is mostly an excuse for Magpie to collect shiny objects, like the “Chrim-Cross Star” on top. All the different writing styles could make the book feel disjointed, but instead it becomes a statement of identity: “ ‘Hey, over here, look at me!’ [Robin chirps], flapping and singing as loudly as a BIRD.” Smith has made Robin a different color than every other character in the book, and it gives her an excuse to try out a rich and layered tint of red. If Rembrandt and Edward Sorel worked together on a picture book, it would look like this. (The book is based on a musical special from Aardman Animations, which, appropriately enough, is animated in a slightly different style, à la Wallace & Gromit.) By the end, Magpie gets a star, and the mice get three different kinds of crumbs.

This story makes a wonderful defense of chaos without being the least bit chaotic.