A group of teenage girls takes social justice into their own hands.
Living in a small town comes with its challenges, and during their last year of high school, five best friends take action, using their birthday wishes to address the multitude of injustices they see in their community on a daily basis. Maddie Carter, Jenny Hoernig, Mags Sharpe, Louise Jantzi, and Jen Dalrymple, all of whom read white, go to school in Eganston, Ontario, and decide to use their privileged status as “good girls” to fight back against harassment, bullying, and intolerance. They start off by poisoning the grass at their local Catholic church in response to the church’s harsh treatment of an 18-year-old who had an abortion. Told in five separate perspectives, this is a true-to-life portrait of teen girls’ friendships; the portrayal of the ties that bind the protagonists is the highlight of the novel. Unfortunately, the premise is flimsy and not fully realized. While the concept of taking their town’s injustices into their own hands is commendable, and the friends mention issues ranging from the arrival of Syrian refugee families to efforts at Reconciliation with Indigenous communities, the surface-level feminism feels hollow, and the girls’ activist values aren’t explored in sufficient depth. Additionally, even though the novel opens with an annotated list of characters, the vast array of cast members is difficult to follow.
An underdeveloped and ultimately unsatisfying read.
(Fiction. 14-18)