A THIEF IN THUNDERCLAN

A cat suspects her clanmates when food goes missing.

This spinoff graphic novel installment focuses on orange and white–furred Brightheart, who lost an eye after a savage dog attack that not only compromised her sight, but also shattered her trust in her Thunderclan clanmates. When her romantic partner, Cloudtail, is assigned an apprentice kit and she is not, Brightheart is disappointed. However, this wears off quickly when she learns she is pregnant with Cloudtail’s kits. Soon, the clan finds their food stores are vanishing each night; Brightheart is suspicious that some of the other cats may not be loyal to Thunderclan, and her reservations deepen as Thunderclan’s leader, Firestar, grows more and more distant. This latest about Hunter and Jolley’s feline empire fails to land on all four paws. The central mystery is resolved hastily, and other plot threads feel as quickly disregarded. Barry’s brightly hued art brings a cinematic feel to the orderly panels, depicting the cats’ world as a harsh juxtaposition of violence and beauty. Long-standing fans of the series may be pleased to revisit this world, but a sagging resolution and the sheer volume of name-dropping may prove too much for a newcomer cat fancier.

Lackluster.