Kirkus Reviews QR Code
I AM NOT A DOG TOY by Ethan T. Berlin

I AM NOT A DOG TOY

by Ethan T. Berlin ; illustrated by Jared Chapman

Pub Date: March 23rd, 2021
ISBN: 978-0-593-11901-3
Publisher: Random House

A spoiled girl rudely rejects a birthday gift of a teddy bear and flings it over to the eagerly rambunctious family dog.

The stuffed bear, welcomed by the dog, insists it is “a fancy kids’ toy with lots of pockets,” and indeed the vest it wears is festooned with them. It is not meant to be a disgusting, chewed, and torn-up dog toy. After being ignored by the little girl one too many times, the bear is eventually thrown into “the wedge” between her bed and the wall to join her other discards. The bear finally relents, giving in to the dog’s persistent cajoling to play and ultimately have lots of fun as a dog toy. Black-outlined cartoons of a scruffy, floppy-eared mutt and a smug brown bear dressed in a utility vest expand on the dialogue-only narrative. The text does not use speech balloons to attribute the dialogue but rather a different typeface for the various characters. Empathy for the bear builds as the girl’s callous actions continue. Choosing friends can be a tricky road to follow in life and rejection a difficult reality to accept. Readers will cheer when the dog’s boundless exuberance eventually counters the girl’s incessant dismissal to create a satisfying bond, and dog lovers will certainly appreciate the sentiments behind the dog’s role in the story. The girl, the only human in the story, is a child of color. (This book was reviewed digitally with 11-by-17-inch double-page spreads viewed at 50% of actual size.)

More Toy Story than Corduroy, a satisfying tale of unexpected friendship.

(Picture book. 5-7)