Turtledove’s 22nd series novel begins yet another trilogy that continues his exploration of an America in which, among other things, the Confederacy won the Civil War and Custer didn’t die at the Little Bighorn. More than 20 major characters from Turtledove’s previous Great War trilogy (Breakthroughs, 2000, etc.) are finding it difficult to pick up the pieces in 1918 after the end of the Great War, which was fought on American soil. The 35 United States (soon to be 36, with the socialist state of Kentucky joining the union) have conquered both Canada and the Confederate States of America, leaving everyone somewhat dazed and confused, including any reader jumping into the series with this installment. After 80 pages, Turtledove introduces his central theme: the rise of an American-style fascism swirling around disgruntled, charismatic former Confederate artillery sergeant Jake Featherstone. Blaming blacks (who staged a brief but significant socialist rebellion in the previous series) and the Confederate military for selling out his nation, Featherstone’s ironically named Freedom Party gains the support of wily aristocratic planter Anne Colleton through her lover, submarine commander Roger Kimball. Meanwhile, President Theodore Roosevelt sends the irascible 78-year-old General Custer to act as provisional commander of Quebec, where Custer is targeted for assassination by bitter Canadian bomber Arthur MacGregor.
As always with Turtledove, there are no clear heroes or villains, just a broad assortment of proud, flawed, skillfully detailed personalities who, when they aren’t talking about politics, make Turtledove’s tediously bewildering alternate America come alive.