MCMILLIONS

A twisty tale of a forgotten scam and the devoted FBI agents who brought it down.

Documentary filmmakers Hernandez and Lazarte, who created the titular HBO series, recount the strange story of con artistry taken to the stratosphere. The chief con, known as “Uncle Jerry,” was a blowhard former cop who talked his way into heading security for an ad agency with an unusual account: handling McDonald’s Monopoly game, which readers may remember from a few decades past. For many years, thanks to Uncle Jerry’s machinations, “all of the winners who walked into various McDonald’s restaurants across the country, waving a winning game piece and claiming a victory over the gods of chance, were cogs in a skillfully crafted conspiracy of fraud.” For a time, Uncle Jerry’s chief lieutenant was a near-stereotypical gangster from the Colombo Mafia family. The setup involved finding a mark to take a winning ticket and then kick back half, plus pay taxes on the whole shebang. Millions of McDonald’s dollars later, the perpetrators had burned a few people in their con. Enter an informant, whose surprising identity the authors reveal at the end, and a forensic accountant from an FBI field office who figured out how to milk confessions from the minions by pretending to be a promotional filmmaker working for McDonald’s. The enterprise fell apart thanks to that oldest of destructive forces, greed. “Most of the ‘criminals’ in this story were merely good people who made a bad choice,” the authors write sympathetically; oddly, some paid a higher price for their greed than did the real criminals. In any event, though heavily covered by the media, the scam went into immediate obscurity, overshadowed by the catastrophic attacks of 9/11.

Though most of the bad guys are deeply unappetizing, true crime buffs will enjoy the cat-and-mouse game of catching them.