Kirkus Reviews QR Code
SCHLEMIEL COMES TO AMERICA by Jane Yolen

SCHLEMIEL COMES TO AMERICA

by Jane Yolen ; illustrated by Óscar T. Pérez

Pub Date: April 1st, 2023
ISBN: 9781478876113
Publisher: Reycraft Books

Don’t count all your fools in one place.

Schlemiel the tailor lives in Chelm, a town in Jewish folklore famous for fools. He fancies himself wise and a shrewd arbiter, and he just might be…at least, compared with the other Chelm residents. Look what happens when the mayor is frightened that a rock on the mountain looming over Chelm might fall. Some citizens carry the rock down to the village, and Schlemiel remarks they could have rolled it down instead. The villagers haul it back up to where they found it—then roll it down, crushing several buildings. Schlemiel decides they’re so foolish, he’s going to America. On the way, he settles a dispute between two people about where a bridge leads, confounds an immigration official, and earns big money when he solves a problem at a construction site involving piles of dirt and holes. Young readers will likely find the stories in this early chapter book mildly amusing—if they get them. However, the artwork is ill-suited to the text. Characters look stiff and bland, and their eyes don’t focus. Scenes and people appear staged, as if posed for a tableau. Characters are light-skinned except for one brown-skinned person on the immigration line. (This book was reviewed digitally.)

A disappointing effort.

(about Chelm) (Chapter book. 6-8)