BIG LAKE TROUBLES

A routine case leads a former judge into a web of intrigue in Boldt’s novel.

Nearly three years after State Administrative Judge Jason Erickson was injured in a shooting that killed his girlfriend Tara, his life in Wisconsin has resumed a semblance of normalcy, including a steady relationship with lawyer Grace Clarkson. One afternoon, Grace asks for his help with a case involving a coal shipment and storage facility located on Lake Superior that wants to renew its permit; she represents a consortium of local and environmental groups opposed to the renewal. Jason’s involvement in the case unites him with a surprising ally: Earl Franks, a disgraced former lawyer whose gambling addiction led to his involvement with the man who shot Jason and Tara. Though Earl has lost his law license, his relevant case experience is an asset, and he genuinely wants to help Grace and Jason. As the case progresses, Jason’s relationship with Grace falters (“Grace had a certain coldness, a façade that he could seldom get behind”) after he meets Camille, a free-spirited Unitarian minister, and Grace rekindles her relationship with colleague Tim Gergen. When Grace and Jason come to suspect the facility is not adequately following environmental regulations, they work with Camille and Earl to surreptitiously obtain coal samples; what seems like a simple plan goes horribly awry, putting careers—and lives—at risk. Boldt’s sequel to Blue Lake (2022) is a captivating page-turner that balances courtroom drama with a deeper exploration of the characters introduced in the author’s debut. Jason Erickson is a strong protagonist whose journey to rebuild his life after losing Tara provides some poignant moments in the novel. The well-drawn supporting characters include Earl Franks, whose redemption arc is nuanced and compelling; Courtney Sharpe, the attorney representing the coal storage facility who has a personal connection to Earl Franks; and Camille, the compassionate minister who offers Jason another chance at love. While this is a direct sequel to Blue Lake, Boldt expertly weaves enough backstory throughout the narrative to establish the connections between the characters for new readers.

A satisfying sequel and one of the best legal thrillers of the year.