Kirkus Reviews QR Code
CAN I KEEP IT, PLEASE? by John Sullivan

CAN I KEEP IT, PLEASE?

by John Sullivan ; illustrated by Jessica Gibson

Pub Date: Aug. 26th, 2025
ISBN: 9781665955560
Publisher: Beach Lane/Simon & Schuster

When young Evie sees the unusual critters on display at the neighborhood pet parade, she decides that her cat Sasha just doesn’t measure up.

“I need a cool pet,” she decides. “Not a plain old cat.” Mom nixes a chinchilla and a skunk; Dad says no to a hedgehog and reminds her about Sasha, whom Evie calls “boring.” Ironically, Sasha solves Evie’s problem by drawing her attention to a garter snake in the bushes. Evie’s folks approve, and Evie learns about snakes and sets up a fine home for her new pet (dubbed Slithers). Doubts soon creep in, however, as the snake spends most of its time hiding in its enclosure. After Evie notices Slithers trying to escape, she releases it into her backyard. Evie apologizes to Sasha, who, happily, has given birth to a litter of kittens—now Evie has four entrants in the next parade! Inspired by a childhood memory of adopting—and eventually freeing—a garter snake he'd caught in a field, Sullivan offers a sweet and well-paced take on responsible pet ownership, starring a protagonist who’s keenly aware of her animals’ needs. Gibson’s colorful cartoonlike illustrations set a cheery tone; Sasha’s especially endearing, maintaining a supportive presence even as Evie’s attention is dominated by Slithers. Evie and her mother are brown-skinned, while Dad is light-skinned; their community is diverse.

A rousing ode to animals who aren’t meant to be pets but instead should be admired from afar: Cheers to them.

(author’s note) (Picture book. 4-7)