BECOMING CHARLEY

Convention is upended in this striking tale of individuality and change.

“Black. Orange. This. Not that.” From the day they are hatched, young caterpillars are informed by their butterfly guardians how to think and how to act. All obey except for Charley. While the others eat ceaselessly, Charley looks up into the canopy and gazes at the trees and clouds and stars. While the others dream of becoming butterflies, Charley imagines what it would be like to be a deer or a waterfall. And as the butterflies tell their charges what to think, Charley finds new things to discover. At last, the day comes for all caterpillars to form their chrysalises, and Charley worries. But while inside, the wayward caterpillar imagines far more than just orange and black, so that when at last the new butterflies emerge, the protagonist’s wings reflect “everything Charley had ever loved.” Storytelling that could have come off as heavy-handed is instead treated here with an elegant touch. Wise produces lush, lovely spreads, not only of the standard monarch colors, but of a world far beyond their perceived limitations. The reveal at the end is evocative of that final spread in Eric Carle’s The Very Hungry Caterpillar (1969) but with an entirely different thought process at work. (This book was reviewed digitally.)

Moralizing bows out in favor of a clever celebration of how our experiences affect our selves.