Kirkus Reviews QR Code
THE NOT-QUITE-PERFECT PASSOVER by Laura Gehl

THE NOT-QUITE-PERFECT PASSOVER

From the Ruby Celebrates! series, volume 4

by Laura Gehl ; illustrated by Olga Ivanov & Aleksey Ivanov

Pub Date: Jan. 26th, 2023
ISBN: 9780807571699
Publisher: Whitman

Things don’t go as expected at an eagerly anticipated seder.

Dad has good and bad news for Ruby. The good: Their family will host the first seder this year. The bad: Their family will host the first seder. Why is this bad news? Bubbe broke her leg, and hosting is a lot of work. But Ruby can’t wait to start. All must be perfect for Bubbe. But little brother Benny messes everything up in his efforts to help—it’s his fault the seder won’t be perfect, Ruby moans. At one point, Dad points out Ruby’s own mistakes, making her even more upset. But eventually, everything gets done, Benny is assigned a doable task to perform at the seder, and the guests arrive. But what’s this? Not-quite-perfect surprises occur—and everyone loves them! Bubbe, in a leg cast, even asks Ruby to help her prepare “a not-quite-perfect seder” next year—and Ruby generously credits Benny for the seder’s nonperfect success. This lightweight, mildly humorous tale makes the clichéd point that all will work out well if you simply try your best—a good point that feels rushed in the telling. The illustrations are colorful and cheery, but characters’ faces are bland and not individualized. Dark-haired Ruby’s family seems to be a single-parent household. Ruby and most of the family members are light-skinned; a child seder guest has dark skin. (This book was reviewed digitally.)

Not quite perfect by any means but a serviceable Passover story.

(note about Passover) (Picture book. 4-7)