A FRIEND LIKE NO OTTER

Sharing her pet stone threatens Otter’s one friendship.

Otter naps clutching Rock to her chest, dresses Rock in seaweed clothing and accessories, and bathes the stone “until Rock sparkles.” Before sleep she “whispers her dreams to Rock. Things that make her happy, or sad, or somewhere in between.” Conveniently (and authentically, for otters), she has an armpit “pocket” where she can tuck Rock. Rock is stolidly passive: Whatever Otter does, “Rock doesn’t mind.” When Manatee asks to play with Otter and Rock, Otter is uncertain but, offered a seagrass accessory for Rock, Otter “can’t say no to a present.” Quiet play suddenly becomes sea-baseball, and Otter’s vigorous thwack sends Rock over Manatee’s head and into the deep. Otter instantly regrets sharing, and though she was the gift-bribed one who let Manatee play and the one who shot Rock into the air, she unreasonably refuses to talk or listen to her friend. Manatee goes to great lengths searching for Rock and, with others’ help, finds Otter’s beloved pal—at which point Otter just resumes playing with her, and “sometimes, they share Rock with others.” If you don’t expect remorse, reflection, or change on Otter’s part, this is a happy ending. Zuill’s pen-and-color style is similar to but somewhat less quirky than the illustrations in Wolf Camp (2016). The two big-eyed animals are slightly anthropomorphized, but several other sea creatures are not. (This book was reviewed digitally.)

Models a less than ideal example of friendship.