HEARTBREAK IS THE NATIONAL ANTHEM

Tracking Taylor Swift from precocious teen to pop-music juggernaut.

Why is Taylor Swift a cultural lightning rod? Why do people love—or hate—her and her music so much? Those are the questions that Sheffield, a music journalist and self-avowed Swiftie, seeks to answer in this zippy and engaging work. Swift has been in the public eye for almost 20 years. Even though she sells out stadiums around the world, she remains an enigma, says Sheffield. “To some,” he writes, “Taylor is a creative genius, a cultural force, a feminist rebel crashing history with her girls-to-the-front energy.” To others, she’s “a symbol of capitalism, privilege, self-absorption, self-pity.…A factory of insipid tearjerkers.” Perhaps it’s because Swift is a shape-shifting mirror, reflecting her fans’ emotional ups and downs. A fan since her country-music days, Sheffield reads her lyrics as if poring over tea leaves. What do they say about her? More importantly, what do they say about him? “When I hear myself in her songs, it’s often the parts of me I try hardest to keep covered up and tied down. I’m threatened by the hairpin trigger in her songs, her constant edge of emotional danger.” Curiously, one doesn’t get much of a sense of what Swift’s music actually sounds like. While Sheffield cites song lyric after song lyric, he describes her music sparingly: “seething electronic pulse…a stark goth-folk sound.” The book is the most engaging when Sheffield shows what Swift means to him. After his mother’s funeral, he found himself singing Swift’s “The Archer” to give voice to his sadness. “Just another heartbroken son yelling Taylor Swift lyrics at four lanes of late-night truckers and bikers and speed freaks and streetlights, none of them impressed.”

An affectionate homage from an ardent fan.