STUPID BABY

A big-brother bunny comes to love his new “stupid baby” brother in this French import by way of New Zealand.

After his mother shushes his noisy play, Simon, an anthropomorphic white rabbit, is displeased when his parents explain that his new baby brother isn’t going back to the hospital after being home for “THREE WHOLE DAYS.” “Go back where you came from, stupid baby,” he says while peering at a sleeping baby bunny in a bassinette. The artwork is minimal, with a cartoon style that will engage readers, though some may be immediately turned off by the text’s casual use of the word stupid. Then the question of how human children will grasp the limits of anthropomorphism arises when a scared Simon can’t sleep at night. He goes to his parents’ room, fearful of imagined wolves outside, and is summarily sent back to bed. As he walks down the hallway, he hears the baby making noises, scoops him up, and brings him back to his own bed, saying “I’ll look after you, my tiny, tiny, stupid baby.” A closing picture shows the brothers sleeping soundly in Simon’s bed as the sun rises outside. Such a resolution would obviously be impractical and unsafe in a human household, which may undermine the book’s relevance to readers who might otherwise identify with Simon.

Not exactly stupid—but not brilliant either.