ON THE SAVAGE SIDE

More Midwestern gothic from the author of Betty (2020).

This story begins in 1979 in Chillicothe, Ohio, an industrial town on the decline. The story’s narrator is Arcade “Arc” Doggs, who's looking back at a time when she was 6 years old. She has a twin sister called Daffy—or Daffodil Poet because she likes to rhyme. They live with their mother, Adelyn, and their Aunt Clover. Both women are heroin addicts and sex workers. When the twins’ grandmother Mamaw Milkweed dies, the girls are left to fend for themselves, and they find community with other lost girls. This novel is inspired by the six women who disappeared from the area around Chillicothe between May and December 2015. But McDaniel moves her narrative back in time, and no one should mistake this novel for a mystery or thriller. This is, instead, an exploration of addiction and grief and an indictment of how we decide who deserves saving. As she did in Betty, McDaniel gives every character the voice of a poet. Everyone—everyone—in this novel speaks like a bard, an oracle, or both. It’s impossible to say much about this novel’s ending without spoiling it, but it’s safe to say that it will be confounding—if not frustrating—for many readers.

McDaniel has attempted a lot here—maybe too much.